Home-Made Yogurt: A Diabetic’s Best Friend

It’s there anyone in the civilized world who hasn’t eaten yogurt? A quick snack or a breakfast mainstay, yogurt has been a “go-to” health food for decades. Or so we thought. It’s anything but if you’re a diabetic, or if you’re simply trying to eat a healthier diet.

Fruit-flavored yogurts are the most popular, and least healthy for diabetics. Not only is the lactose in yogurt a form of milk sugar, but fruit-flavored yogurts can contain over 46 grams of added sugar. 

Even the sugar-free variety contains added ingredients, artificial sweeteners that taste sweet but add zero nutritional value. Many of us can’t fully digest such additives well, and then there’s the whole issue of eating anything artificial.

Which leads us, thankfully, with plain yogurt. Being plain, you have the opportunity to sweeten it with a whole host of options, and top it with even more. If you make a small investment and a bit of time, you can now easily and inexpensively, make your own plain yogurt.

Recently, I bought a Donvier Yogurt Maker.  YogurtMakerIt comes complete with the machine itself, 8 yogurt cups and covers, a thermometer and instructions. It’s about as fool-proof as it can be.

Using the thermometer, heat 5C of milk (the instructions say 4C…we found we could easily push this to 5 for a slightly larger Yogurt4portion) to about 180F. While this is happening, fill your sink with ice water. When you’ve reached the right temperature, transfer the milk to a big metal bowl and float it in the ice Yogurt5water to cool it quickly. Again, using the thermometer, bring the temperature down to about 110F…this spot is clearly marked for you on the thermometer.

Transfer 2-3T of the milk into one of the yogurt containers. Add about 2t of plain yogurt you already have on hand. Put the lid on the container and shake it really well. Take the lid off and empty the contents into the cooled milk, and stir well (I use a whisk for this).

At this point, I like to pour the milk into a large Pyrex measuring class to distribute the milk evenly amongst the 8 containers. Put the tops on the containers, pressing down to get a good seal. Cover the container, and set the timer. We’ve Yogurt9found that 10 1/2 hours gives us the consistency and flavor we find most appealing. When ready, pop the caps, pour off any extra water and recap. Chill for a couple of hours and you’re good to go.

Note: the longer you let the yogurt “cook”, the firmer and more tangy it will be. To make a “greek sytle” yogurt, simply put a YogurtGreekpaper coffee filter in a small colander over a bowl, empty one to two containers into it, and let it sit for about 30 minutes. Smoooooth…

Kent McDonald is a Certified Personal Chef, living and working in Phoenix, AZ. (c) All Rights Reserved, 2013

3 thoughts on “Home-Made Yogurt: A Diabetic’s Best Friend

  1. Pingback: Saturday Creative Round-Up | QuinnCreative

  2. Hi, Carolyn,
    I keep 2% in the house, and used it for this blog. But there’s no reason why you can’t use whole or skim milk. Whole milk with give you a richer yogurt with a more creamy mouth feel (adding a spot of heavy cream to the mix gives you an incredible mouth feel). Skim of course will produce a much less rich mouth feel as it has far less fat. Hope this helps, and thanks for your comment.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s